The tragic cause why a global lawyer sued the Victorian Authorities after being trapped in lodge quarantine can lastly be revealed.
Hayden Flinn’s two-week court docket battle over the state’s choice to refuse him and his son a quarantine exemption was set to start on Tuesday earlier than it was quietly settled on the morning of the trial.
No particulars have been launched on the settlement, however the Day by day Mail can reveal Mr Flinn and his son had flown from Hong Kong to Melbourne in Could 2021.
Sophie, Mr Flinn’s troubled 13-year-old daughter, had simply taken her personal life on Could 2.
However regardless of Mr Flinn and his son each being totally vaccinated, Victorian well being officers insisted they be held in a Melbourne lodge below Victoria’s strict quarantine legal guidelines.
They had been nonetheless trapped there for an extra two weeks whereas the remainder of the household grieved with out them and deliberate {the teenager}’s funeral.
Sophie had been a proficient basketballer, who had studied on the Australian Worldwide College in Hong Kong, the place her dad stays a governor.
Mr Flinn had been in Hong Kong the place he works as a company lawyer, when phrase of his daughter’s dying reached him.
Sophie Flinn, 13, tragically took her personal life as Victorians confronted their fourth Covid-19 lockdown
The devastated father accomplished two Covid checks, which each turned up destructive, and flew aboard a Cathay Pacific flight into Melbourne as a totally vaccinated traveller with two doses of Pfizer.
What adopted subsequent was a traumatic two weeks locked in a small Richmond lodge room along with his distraught teenage son after the pair had been refused permission to quarantine with household at residence.
On Could 3, 2021, the day after Sophie died, there was only one new case of Covid-19 recorded in Victoria and no new regionally acquired circumstances.
The state had not been in lockdown since February.
On the time, Victorians had already been punished via three lockdowns that started in March the earlier yr.
After 159 days in isolation, Victorians had been simply weeks away from their fourth Covid-19 lockdown, which started on Could 27 and ran till June 10 that yr.
In his now settled lawsuit, Mr Flinn claimed he was barred from viewing his daughter’s physique and couldn’t be along with his distressed spouse as she deliberate their little one’s funeral.
He sued the state of Victoria and the Division of Well being for damages, claiming he suffered ‘indignity and insult’, a lack of liberty and psychological misery.
The trial was set to listen to from a string of witnesses together with former chief well being officer Brett Sutton and his deputy, Allen Cheng, in regards to the decision-making course of round Mr Flinn’s case and different exemptions given in the course of the pandemic.
Hayden Flinn (centre) arrives on the Supreme Court docket of Victoria on Tuesday in what was speculated to be the beginning of his civil trial in opposition to the Victorian Authorities. It had already been settled
Court docket paperwork in Mr Flinn’s case alleged the federal government was conscious of why he wanted to go away, however continued to carry him in quarantine, The Age reported.
‘The extent of misery being skilled by the household was assessed as too excessive for the household to take care of [detention] necessities,’ a Well being Division e mail, despatched on Could 4, 2021, learn.
‘The choice of going residence to spouse and household would pose a COVID-19 danger to household and public well being.’
Mr Flinn had alleged ‘the choices recorded in Detention Notices 1 and a couple of had been illegal and/or incorrect’, court docket paperwork said.
Court docket information contained an e mail despatched from Mr Flinn to the Well being Division asking it to let him and his son out.
‘Her physique is on the Coroner’s Court docket. I wish to go away the lodge to see her. Thanks. Hayden,’ he wrote.
When his request was denied, he emailed the Well being Division once more, elevating fears of his teenage son being locked in a room with him whereas he was in a state of extreme grief.
As emails continued to bounce between completely different departments, together with Sutton’s, it was confirmed the household’s exemption request to maneuver to residence quarantine had been denied.
Within the three weeks earlier than Mr Flinn’s request, authorities information confirmed Covid-19 Quarantine Victoria was made conscious of 236 exemption requests, 4 of which had been accepted on the grounds of remarkable medical wants.
Former chief well being officer Brett Sutton was the mastermind of Victoria’s covid response
Mr Flinn and his son had been lastly allowed to go away the lodge about 5.30pm on Could 17, 2021, after finishing their fortnight of seclusion.
His daughter was laid to relaxation on Could 22, 2021, virtually three weeks after her dying.
The Day by day Mail doesn’t recommend Sophie’s dying was linked to any lockdown or Covid restriction.
Whereas the settlement determine will probably stay confidential, authorized sources recommend it was substantial, given the company lawyer’s enthusiasm to take the case to trial.
Mr Flinn was set to deal with reporters about his case on Thursday however pulled out after the case was formally settled.
The Day by day Mail contacted him for remark however didn’t obtain a response.
porty legislation pupil Natalie Boyce was 21 when she died on March 27, 2022 at The Alfred hospital in Melbourne, 5 weeks after receiving a Moderna vaccine booster
Earlier this week, in a wholly completely different case within the Coroners Court docket of Victoria, Coroner Catherine Fitzgerald heard in regards to the dying of Natalie Boyce, 21, 5 weeks after a Moderna booster, and about how Covid hospital visiting restrictions affected her mom, single mum Deborah Hamilton.
Ms Hamilton has lengthy accused former Premier Daniel Andrews of getting particular therapy whereas he was in hospital with an injured again in 2021.
She claimed an Alfred nurse instructed her that Mr Andrews was allowed guests each time he needed, with no cut-off dates, whereas he was in hospital.
Ms Hamilton instructed a Senate committee in Could 2023: ‘Daniel Andrews compelled us.’
‘I believe Dan Andrews is probably the most corrupt particular person on the market, and I don’t perceive why he has completely different guidelines than the remainder of us.
‘It’s simply so unfair.’
In March 2026, the Victorian Authorities, below former Premier Jacinta Allan, settled a category motion introduced by retail companies for $125million over the lodge quarantine debacle.
The settlement was accepted by the Supreme Court docket of Victoria on October 21.
Daniel Andrews throughout his hospital keep in 2021. Deborah Hamilton has accused him of receiving particular therapy
That declare alleged that operational failures within the lodge quarantine program, significantly outbreaks linked to the Rydges and Stamford Plaza accommodations, brought on Victoria’s second Covid-19 wave and the following Stage 3 and Stage 4 lockdowns from July to October 2020.
The Victorian Authorities settled with out admitting any wrongdoing.
In case you or somebody you understand wants help, contact Lifeline on 13 11 14 or Past Blue on 1300 22 4636. In an emergency, name Triple Zero on 000














