Chinese language carmaker BYD’s ‘copycat Defender’ has been banned from being bought within the European Union after judges dominated it had infringed on Jaguar Land Rover’s mental property rights.
The Britain-based firm now hopes the ban will prolong to the UK following the ruling in The Hague on Friday, which imposed an injunction throughout the EU however not on this aspect of the Channel.
JLR is shifting to take its declare towards BYD to UK courts earlier than deliveries of the Chinese language ‘copy’ of its bestselling automobile hit British markets in January.
The involvement of the courts is the most recent episode of the continuing feud between the automobile makers.
Representatives of the JLR raided BYD’s Dutch workplaces in Schiedam and Hoofddorp over the summer time to grab ‘digital property’.
JLR mentioned the paperwork taken within the raid proved that BYD’s so-called ‘copycat Defender’ could be launched exterior of China. Nevertheless, BYD mentioned that they had no concrete plans to carry their automobile to the EU market.
If allowed to be bought within the UK, the Chinese language automobile – formally known as the Fangchengbao Ti7 – could be priced at £47,995 – about £20,000 lower than the most affordable Defender.
The Dutch court docket ordered JLR to return the information its bailiffs had seized, however sources mentioned the carmaker nonetheless handled it as a victory for the intelligence it had gathered.
BYD’s ‘copycat Defender’, the Ti7, has been banned from being bought or produced within the EU after a decide in The Hague dominated it infringed JLR’s mental property rights
The Defender is JLR’s hottest mannequin, with world gross sales of over 100,000 models in 2025. BYD’s mannequin could be bought for about £20,000 lower than JLR’s least expensive Defender
The Defender is JLR’s hottest mannequin, with world gross sales of over 100,000 models in 2025.
Commentators have identified the visible similarities between the 2 rival automobile designs.
Each have a boxy, flat-roof silhouette, upright proportions, shoulders with rounded corners, tailgate styling, squared-off wheel arches, the continual glasshouse and a stable body-coloured panel behind the rear passenger door.
The court docket ruling decreed: ‘The Ti7 infringes the EU design of Jaguar Land Rover,’ including, ‘The attribute and distinctive components of the design are mirrored within the BYD Ti7.’
The ruling additionally banned BYD from producing the automobile at its new manufacturing unit in Hungary, which is because of begin mass-producing autos early subsequent yr.
However the court docket had no jurisdiction over BYD’s affiliate in the UK, the decide mentioned.
It’s uncommon for design circumstances like these to go to court docket like this in Europe. Additionally it is unusual for a ruling like this to return so early in a case that’s ongoing and can final for a while.
‘We defend our mental property and take authorized motion when vital,’ JLR mentioned in a press release. ‘Authorized proceedings are ongoing, and we can’t be commenting additional at the moment.’
BYD hit again in its assertion, saying it ‘strongly disagrees’ with the ruling and can enchantment it.
‘The BYD Ti 7 is the results of BYD’s personal impartial design work and infringes none of JLR’s rights,’ a spokesperson mentioned. ‘We are going to pursue each authorized avenue to show that this choice is inaccurate.’
Legacy automakers have usually complained that Chinese language automakers have copied designs, although little has been confirmed in court docket.
One such Chinese language producer is Chery, which has just lately made waves within the UK market with the Jaecoo 7.
It has been awarded the nickname ‘Temu Vary Rover’ – referencing a budget Chinese language buying app – as a result of its similarities with the JLR automobile.
Chinese language carmaker Chery’s Jaecoo 7 has been nicknamed ‘Temu Vary Rover’ over its similarities to the JLR automobile. It was the bestselling automobile in Britain final month
Friday’s ruling in The Hague contrasts with failed makes an attempt by JLR to say logos of their Vary Rover Evoque and Defender in 2015 and 2020, respectively
It is bought for about £10,000 lower than its JLR counterpart nevertheless, and have become the bestselling automobile in Britain final month.
Chery had a row with Common Motors in 2005 too over the Chery QQ, which the primary US carmaker mentioned was a replica of its Chevrolet Spark. They settled the case exterior of court docket.
Friday’s ruling in The Hague contrasts with failed makes an attempt by JLR to say logos of their Vary Rover Evoque and Defender in 2015 and 2020, respectively.
The British carmaker now has six months to start full proceedings. The present ruling applies in all 27 EU member international locations – barring import, manufacturing, providing on the market, sale, storage and supply of the Ti7.
BYD has grown quickly in Europe since launching gross sales on the continent in late 2022.
In keeping with ACEA knowledge, the Chinese language automaker’s gross sales greater than doubled to over 280,000 autos in Europe this yr by September, in contrast with the identical interval final yr, outselling Ford, Tesla and Nissan.














