Investigators have revealed that they moved to arrest the suspected Gilgo Beach serial killer as a consequence of fears that he may strike once more.
Rex Heuermann, 59, was dramatically arrested Thursday night time in midtown Manhattan outdoors his architectural workplace on Fifth Avenue, 13 years after the victims’ our bodies have been discovered on an remoted Lengthy Island seaside.
Cops had Heuermann underneath surveillance since final yr, and had deliberate to proceed to comply with him as they constructed their case, however determined to swoop in and make the arrest within the curiosity of ‘public security,’ Suffolk County District Lawyer Ray Tierney advised reporters.
Tierney cited numerous purple flags, saying that Heuermann ‘continued to patronize intercourse employees,’ was utilizing false IDs and burner telephones, and had permits for an astonishing 92 firearms.
‘Which after all made us very nervous,’ mentioned Tierney, who has led a secret investigative job drive targeted on Heuermann for the reason that spring of 2022.
Flanked by relations of the victims as he addressed reporters, Suffolk County Police Commissioner Rodney Harrison delivered a grim evaluation of the suspect, saying: ‘Rex Heuermann is a demon that walks amongst us, a predator that ruined households.’
Manhattan architect Rex Heuermann, 59, is charged with three murders attributed to the Gilgo Seaside serial killer, and is the prime suspect in a fourth sufferer’s homicide
Suffolk County District Lawyer Ray Tierney mentioned Heuermann had been underneath surveillance since final yr, and cops moved in to arrest him over fears he would strike once more
At an arraignment hearing on Friday, Tierney advised the courtroom his groups had been following Heuermann since final yr and deliberate to proceed to take action as they constructed the case, however feared he was about to flee the nation.
Later, at a press convention, he and different regulation enforcement officers have been involved that Heuermann may goal different victims if he remained free.
‘We had the FBI surveilling the defendant… this person that continued to patronize intercourse employees in any respect hours of the night time, continued to make use of fictitious emails, identities, burner telephones,’ mentioned Tierney.
‘As we labored via the case and received nearer and nearer, all of a sudden the stability suggestions in favor of public security,’ he mentioned.
‘We wished as a job drive to proceed it however we felt collectively as a job drive that it was time to strike that stability and take him off the road.’
Tierney mentioned Heuermann has permits for 92 firearms which haven’t but been accounted for, however added that they could be present in a big protected at Heurmann’s dwelling.
‘He has a really massive protected wherein weapons are stored,’ he mentioned. ‘We’re persevering with to execute search warrants, so I am positive we’ll have that reply shortly.’
It isn’t clear whether or not investigators consider firearms have been utilized in any of the murders. The victims’ stays have been found in a decomposed state that difficult efforts to find out their accidents.
‘Forensically there was not lots that might be achieved with the stays,’ mentioned Tierney.
The DA signaled that costs towards Heuermann could be anticipated in a fourth homicide, however mentioned that sure forensic assessments have been nonetheless underway in that case when cops determined to make the arrest.
‘The preliminary plan was to permit the grand jury investigation to go a little bit additional, however at a sure time the duty drive felt that — for causes having nothing to do with the proof within the case — we would have liked to take him down,’ he mentioned.
Heuermann, who has lived for many years throughout a bay from the place the stays have been discovered, is charged with killing Melissa Barthelemy, Megan Waterman and Amber Costello.
He’s additionally thought of the prime suspect within the loss of life of a fourth girl, Maureen Brainard-Barnes, whose physique was certain and hidden in thick underbrush alongside a distant seaside freeway, authorities mentioned.
A complete of 11 our bodies have been discovered on a desolate stretch of Ocean Parkway over the course of a number of months in 2010 and 2011. A lot of the victims have been younger ladies who had been intercourse employees.
Tierney declined to say whether or not Heurmann is suspected within the different murders, saying his job drive was targeted on the 4 victims tied to Heurmann, including that these 4 instances had distinct ‘commonalities’.
He cited the necessity to keep investigative secrecy as the opposite murders are investigated, however vowed to proceed pursuing justice for all of the victims.
He’s additionally thought of the prime suspect within the loss of life of a fourth girl, Maureen Brainard-Barnes, whose physique was certain and hidden in thick underbrush alongside a distant seaside freeway
Crime scene investigators carry out proof from the Massapequa Park dwelling of Rex Heuermann who was arrested as a suspect within the Gilgo Seaside serial killing
Investigators are seen eradicating potential proof from the house. The DA revealed that Heuermann had permits for 92 weapons, and a big gun protected in his dwelling
Protection legal professional Michael Brown (above) mentioned his consumer had advised him, ‘I didn’t do that’
Heuermann’s lawyer entered a not responsible plea on his behalf Friday in state courtroom in Riverhead. Choose Richard Ambro ordered him held with out bail, citing ‘the intense depravity’ of his alleged crimes.
Throughout an preliminary courtroom look, Heuermann appeared smug – puffing his cheeks out and nodding as among the costs have been learn. He wore khaki pants and a grey collared shirt, and didn’t communicate in courtroom.
He pleaded not responsible to all six costs – three counts of first diploma homicide, and three of second diploma homicide.
After the listening to, his legal professional Michael Brown mentioned his consumer had cried out to him saying, ‘I didn’t do that.’
Prosecutors say a trove of proof connects him to the murders, together with DNA recovered from a pizza crust Heuermann tossed out that matched genetic materials discovered on the ladies’s stays.
Prosecutors allege different proof tying Heuermann to the murders consists of:
- His spouse’s DNA was discovered on three of the victims’ our bodies
- One in every of his personal hairs was discovered on one of many victims’ our bodies
- Calls made out of a burner telephone to the victims have been traced to his workplace
- A name made to one of many victims’ sisters after she died was traced to his workplace
- His Tinder profile with pictures of him was linked to the burner telephone quantity
- His private telephones all the time pinged in the identical areas because the suspect burners
- His Chevrolet pick-up truck matched the suspect automobile noticed by a witness
- He matches the bodily description of ‘ogre’ like man seen with one sufferer
- Heuermann performed graphic searches for youngster porn and sexual torture
- He additionally searched Google for updates on the case, looking ‘why may regulation enforcement not hint the calls made by the lengthy island serial killer’
Chatting with reporters, DA Tierney addressed the lengthy delay between the invention of the our bodies and the identification of a suspect.
Tierney mentioned he convened a grand jury investigation after Heuermann’s title first got here to the eye of investigators as a doable suspect in March 2022, when he was recognized as as soon as proudly owning an equivalent truck to 1 seen by witnesses when a sufferer disappeared in 2010.
In March, detectives tailing Heuermann recovered his DNA from pizza crust in a field that he discarded in a Manhattan trash can and matched it to a hair discovered on a restraint used within the killings, authorities mentioned.
The DA mentioned he used the investigative powers of the grand jury to difficulty greater than 300 subpoenas and summon witnesses, whereas sustaining strict secrecy to keep away from alerting the suspect to progress within the investigation.
He steered that prior efforts to resolve the case had been too public, and influenced by outdoors elements.
‘The rationale why these investigations fell brief prior to now was as a result of there was a variety of outdoors affect, lots of people who had nothing to do with the investigation or any of the businesses, they nonetheless asserted stress,’ he mentioned.
‘That didn’t occur with our job drive. Ours was run by our members and we did what we thought was in the perfect curiosity of the investigation.’
Heuermann lives in Massapequa Park, a neighborhood simply north of South Oyster Bay and the sandy stretch generally known as Gilgo Seaside the place the victims’ stays have been discovered.
The proof towards Heuermann was specified by a 32-page letter by Suffolk County DA’s Workplace explaining why he should not be granted bail.
It particulars how a brand new job drive arrange by Suffolk County DA final yr got here throughout his title inside months of investigation, prompting questions on why earlier investigative items did not nail him.
Heuermann’s first hyperlink to the case is thru the Chevrolet Avalanche truck that he owned in 2009 and 2010, when the ladies have been murdered.
The automobile was seen on the properties of a minimum of one of many victims the day earlier than she went lacking.
Heuermann additionally matches the outline of an ‘ogre’ like man visited one of many victims the night time earlier than she died.
In that case, he’s mentioned to have organized a gathering with Amber Costello for intercourse at her dwelling.
Costello and a male buddy performed a ‘ruse’ whereby the male buddy pretended to interrupt their hook-up, claiming he was an offended boyfriend.
The person who’d paid for intercourse was pressured to depart, together with his cash on the desk.
Rex Heuermann is proven in one in all his Tinder profile footage. Police tracked the fictional e-mail account he used on the profile and his burner telephone quantity to the case
Heurmann in one other of the pictures he used on the relationship app. He’s mentioned to have despatched the pictures to ladies asking for hook-ups
In January this yr, after watching Heuermann and his household since final March, the detectives within the case seized a pizza field he’d thrown within the trash outdoors his Manhattan workplace
The pizza field taken from a trash can outdoors Heuermann’s midtown workplace
These are among the searches performed on Heuermann’s pc
These are the sick Google searches performed on Heuermann’s pc
Heuermann is proven shopping for extra minutes for one more burner cellphone in Could this yr. He paid money
Afterwards, he texted Costello saying ‘that wasn’t very good’ and demanding a ‘credit score’ on his subsequent service.
Costello met with the shopper once more the next night time, however she he insisted on doing so away from her dwelling.
The witness mentioned the shopper was between 6ft 4 and 6ft 6, with a broad body and glasses.
He lived close by in Massapequa Park, the place he nonetheless resides together with his household, however his Icelandic spouse was out of city when the murders occurred.
Along with the automobile matching the automobile seen on the sufferer’s dwelling, police have been in a position to hint telephone calls made out of a burner telephone to the victims to arrange rendezvous to the areas surrounding his dwelling and his Manhattan workplace.
New York Metropolis architect Rex Heuermann, 59, has been arrested in reference to Lengthy Island’s Gilgo Seaside murders, in a bombshell breakthrough in one of many nation’s most infamous unsolved serial killer instances
One other name was made to one of many victims’ kin after she vanished. That decision was traced to his workplace.
He additionally used fictitious e-mail accounts and extra burner telephone numbers for a Tinder profile, the place he posted pictures of himself, years later.
Along with the arduous proof linking him to the precise murders, Heuermann performed additionally performed incriminating web searches.
Amongst them have been search phrases like ‘
He additionally performed heinous Google searches for youngster porn and violent sexual photographs of ladies being tortured.
In January this yr, after watching Heuermann and his household since final March, the detectives within the case seized a pizza field he’d thrown within the trash outdoors his Manhattan workplace.
His DNA from one of many crusts was a 99.6 % match to a male hair discovered on the backside of the burlap sack one of many victims was present in.
Prosecutors additionally found unidentified feminine hairs on three of the victims.
They initially traced Heuermann to the case by matching an outline of his Chevrolet truck to the automobile he owned on the time of the murders.
The automobile was seen on the dwelling of Amber Costello, one of many victims, who vanished on September 2, 2010.
The road in Massapequa Park, Lengthy Island, the place a suspect was this morning arrested in reference to the Gilgo Seaside murders
Heuermann’s truck was faraway from the house this afternoon
Representatives from The Workplace of Chief Medical Examiner of the Metropolis of New York exit the workplace constructing of Rex Heuermann
Representatives from The Workplace of Chief Medical Examiner of the Metropolis of New York exit the workplace constructing of Rex Heuermann, at 385 fifth Avenue in New York Metropolis, and re-enter the constructing with extra provides and gloves on July 14, 2023
Chilling similarities could be drawn between Heuermann, a married father-of-two, and the unknown suspect described in a 2011 FBI profile of the Gilgo Seaside killer.
That profile described a ‘sadistic however charming common Joe’, who may mix into any atmosphere unnoticed.
Heuermann lived a seemingly regular, ‘common Joe’ life till his dramatic arrest.
The profilers advised The New York Times that the suspect was possible financially secure and brilliant.
‘He might have sought therapy at a hospital for poison ivy an infection. As a part of his job or pursuits, he has entry to, or a stockpile of, burlap sacks,’ the profile learn.
Heuermann grew up in Massapequa Park, attending highschool with Billy Baldwin, and began working in Manhattan in 1987.
Heuermann was married as soon as in 1990 and once more years later to his present spouse, Asa Ellerup, who’s of Iceland descent.
He and Asa have an grownup daughter Victoria, who works with Heuermann at his architectural agency, and a stepson, Asa’s son from a earlier marriage.
A part of his job was to barter between the town of New York’s Division of Buildings and personal architects.
In a 2022 video, Heuermann boasted about his architectural profession working with New York Metropolis’s Division of Buildings.
‘I used to be born and raised on Lengthy Island and have been working in Manhattan since 1987. A really very long time!’ he advised Bonjour Realty.